Ideas for password management

Disclaimer I am not a security expert by any means.

Remembering passwords has been always a huge pain for me and storing them (even in an encrypted form) always felt very vulnerable. After all, getting access to the storage could lead to a massive leak. One master password, private key, hardware – to me, those are all single points of failure.

Back in 2011, I came across an HN thread with the idea of generating passwords on demand, every time you need one, based on keys you store in your own, mental memory (or a thought process, so you associate notions instead of actually remembering terms). One could argue that’s a single point of failure too (dementia anyone?), but in my naive sense of security, I found the idea very appealing.

The idea is simple: you use HMAC along with a “target domain” and a secret scheme of keys stored/produced in your head. As far as I understand, the strength of HMAC lies in the length of the secret used, so that’s something to keep in mind too. The reason I’m mentioning keys in plural is, you can diversify the way of building your secret, so:

  • it’s not really obvious what the “target domain” is (can be tumblr for your cat pics and for things you care about)
  • you can associate “target domains” with categories/schemes to quickly find a mental path to the key you’re looking for (whatever123 vs i very much care about cats)
  • you are free to add anything you like to the generated final password and that’s yet another random and unpredictable key in the pool. It’s obviously easier to remember a way to figure out the keys, than to remember the passwords you frequently use.

The next step is to build a generator that produces passwords having all the properties that comply with the odd requirements most sites enforce. And more, it’s really up to you.

Based on the comments I found in the mentioned HN thread, I took a stab at writing such generator. You can check out the source here.

For the sake of clarity, I use a slightly modified version, but mind your own business :-), the principle stays the same.

The utility is simple – it prompts you for the target domain and a password (being your secret, diversified HMAC key) and writes the target password to the standard output.

With p() { passy "$*" | pbcopy; } function in your .zshrc you can:

$  p
Password: <bar>

and QhhRuvC@RSGZS@:dY:KX^,S,%+Kn^:X`G:rg lands in your clipboard. Append it with hurr durr and you’ve got a pretty strong password.

Of course this particular implementation has its flaws, for instance:

  • it leaves a trace in your shell history (unless you prepend the call with a space – at least in zsh; see the shell snippet above).
  • it’s not cross-platform (in this case it depends on shell/python runtime – on mobile you really have to go the extra mile)
  • it’s vulnerable to keyloggers
  • etc.

The pros, on the other hand:

  • it’s completely custom (don’t get me wrong, do not roll your own crypto) – it is nearly impossible to guess what generator is in use
  • nothing is persisted

So as long as someone’s not holding a gun to your head, maybe give this a shot.